What should I sell to my audience?
Most creators approach this as a decision to be made, sitting down to choose between an ebook, a course and a template pack. It is closer to a reading exercise, and the material you need has already been written by other people.
The answer is usually already sitting in your comments and your DMs. How to find the thing people keep asking you for, how to price it without flinching, and the two mistakes that kill a first product.
The question is pointing the wrong way
“What should I sell” puts you at the centre, picking from a menu. The version that works turns it around: what do people keep asking me for?
That question has an answer already, and you do not have to guess it. It is sitting in places you already own.
- Your comments. Not the praise. The questions, especially the ones you have answered more than twice.
- Your DMs and email. The requests you keep typing the same reply to.
- Your most-replayed moments. If YouTube shows you a spike on one section, people came back to that bit deliberately. Watch it again and ask what they were trying to get from it.
- The video you did not want to make. Many channels have one piece that outperformed and felt off-brand. It may be the audience telling you what they came for.
Open your last fifty comments and write down every question, in the asker’s words. Do not tidy the phrasing. When the same question appears five or six times, you are looking at your product, and you are also looking at its sales page, because their wording is better than yours.
If nothing repeats, that is a result too. It means the audience has not formed a clear expectation of you yet, and a product launched into that will not land. Keep publishing and run the exercise again in three months.
Match the format to the problem
The format follows from what the person is stuck on, and getting this wrong can make good material sell badly.
Somebody who is missing information wants a guide or an ebook, and they want it cheap and immediate. Somebody who is missing a process wants a course or a structured walkthrough, because their problem is sequencing rather than facts. Somebody who is missing time wants templates, presets or files, and they will pay more for less content, because you are selling the hours they do not have to spend. Somebody who is missing confidence wants access to you, which is coaching or a community, and that is the most expensive thing on the list and the hardest to deliver.
Read your collected questions again with those four in mind. Usually one dominates, and it will not always be the one you find most interesting to make.
Validate before you build
The expensive mistake is spending eight weeks making the thing and then discovering what people wanted. Reverse that order.
Describe the product publicly in a sentence or two, and ask directly whether people would want it. Put a version of it in front of a small number of people before it exists at full size: a live workshop instead of a recorded course, a short document instead of a book, a single template instead of a pack. What you are buying with that is the answer to whether anyone will pay, and you buy it for a weekend instead of two months.
Treat a lot of enthusiasm and no money as a no. The reliable signal is somebody choosing to pay.
Pricing, and the flinch
Many first products are priced too low out of nerve.
A low price does not make selling easier. It leaves you no room to support the product properly, and it forces volume: far more of your audience has to buy before it was worth making. Pricing a product at the level where you would feel comfortable defending it out loud is usually closer to correct than the number you first thought of.
Price against the outcome rather than the file size. Twelve pages that save somebody a week of work are worth more than a 200-page book that entertains them. Buyers are paying for what changes after they read it.
“After using this, you will be able to ______.” If you cannot finish it concretely, the price is not the problem and you are not ready to sell it yet.
The two mistakes that kill a first product
Launching once and never again. Many in your audience will miss the announcement. They were not on the app that day, or the video did not reach them. A single launch tests your timing at least as much as it tests your product, and it is easy to conclude nobody wanted it when hardly anyone saw it. Mention it regularly and without apology, and give it a permanent home in your description and your pinned comment.
Selling to the wrong slice. Your audience is not one group. A channel about a craft usually has beginners who want to start, improvers who are stuck, and a long tail who are there to watch rather than to do. A product aimed at everyone lands with the third group, who are the least likely to buy, and misses the first two. Pick one of them and say which in the title.
The trust you are spending
Selling something to people who trust you changes the relationship, and pretending otherwise is how creators get this wrong. Your audience extends you credit the first time on the strength of everything you have published for free. They will not extend it twice if the thing disappoints.
So the standard is higher than in a normal transaction.
Go and read what people keep asking you.
Common questions
What should I sell if my audience is still small?
Size matters less than clarity. A few hundred people with one repeated question is a better starting point than fifty thousand casual viewers with no shared problem. If nothing repeats in your comments yet, keep publishing and run the comment exercise again in a few months.
How much should I charge for my first digital product?
Price against the outcome rather than the length. A short document that saves somebody a week is worth more than a long one that entertains them. Many first products are underpriced out of nerve.
Should I make a course or an ebook?
It depends on what the person is stuck on. A guide suits someone who lacks information, a course suits someone who needs a sequence to follow, templates and files suit someone short of time, and coaching or a community suits someone who mainly lacks confidence. Read your own collected questions and one of those will usually dominate.
Nobody bought my product. What went wrong?
Before rewriting it, check how many people actually saw it. A single launch reaches a small fraction of an audience, so a quiet week often measures timing rather than demand. The other common cause is aiming at the whole audience instead of one clearly named group within it.
If this helped, say so. It is how we pick what to write next.
Comments